The Korea Times
amn_close.png
amn_bl.png
National
  • Politics
  • Foreign Affairs
  • Multicultural Community
  • Defense
  • Environment & Animals
  • Law & Crime
  • Society
  • Health & Science
amn_bl.png
Business
  • Tech
  • Bio
  • Companies
  • World Expo 2030
amn_bl.png
Finance
  • Companies
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Cryptocurrency
amn_bl.png
Opinion
  • Editorial
  • Columns
  • Thoughts of the Times
  • Cartoon
  • Today in History
  • Blogs
  • Tribune Service
  • Blondie & Garfield
  • Letter to the Editor
amn_bl.png
Lifestyle
  • Travel & Food
  • Trends
  • People & Events
  • Books
  • Around Town
  • Fortune Telling
amn_bl.png
Entertainment & Arts
  • K-pop
  • Films
  • Shows & Dramas
  • Music
  • Theater & Others
amn_bl.png
Sports
  • Hangzhou Asian Games
amn_bl.png
World
  • SCMP
  • Asia
amn_bl.png
Video
  • Korean Storytellers
  • POPKORN
  • Culture
  • People
  • News
amn_bl.png
Photos
  • Photo News
  • Darkroom
amn_NK.png amn_DR.png amn_LK.png amn_LE.png
  • bt_fb_on_2022.svgbt_fb_over_2022.svg
  • bt_twitter_on_2022.svgbt_twitter_over_2022.svg
  • bt_youtube_on_2022.svgbt_youtube_over_2022.svg
  • bt_instagram_on_2022.svgbt_instagram_over_2022.svg
The Korea Times
amn_close.png
amn_bl.png
National
  • Politics
  • Foreign Affairs
  • Multicultural Community
  • Defense
  • Environment & Animals
  • Law & Crime
  • Society
  • Health & Science
amn_bl.png
Business
  • Tech
  • Bio
  • Companies
  • World Expo 2030
amn_bl.png
Finance
  • Companies
  • Economy
  • Markets
  • Cryptocurrency
amn_bl.png
Opinion
  • Editorial
  • Columns
  • Thoughts of the Times
  • Cartoon
  • Today in History
  • Blogs
  • Tribune Service
  • Blondie & Garfield
  • Letter to the Editor
amn_bl.png
Lifestyle
  • Travel & Food
  • Trends
  • People & Events
  • Books
  • Around Town
  • Fortune Telling
amn_bl.png
Entertainment & Arts
  • K-pop
  • Films
  • Shows & Dramas
  • Music
  • Theater & Others
amn_bl.png
Sports
  • Hangzhou Asian Games
amn_bl.png
World
  • SCMP
  • Asia
amn_bl.png
Video
  • Korean Storytellers
  • POPKORN
  • Culture
  • People
  • News
amn_bl.png
Photos
  • Photo News
  • Darkroom
amn_NK.png amn_DR.png amn_LK.png amn_LE.png
  • bt_fb_on_2022.svgbt_fb_over_2022.svg
  • bt_twitter_on_2022.svgbt_twitter_over_2022.svg
  • bt_youtube_on_2022.svgbt_youtube_over_2022.svg
  • bt_instagram_on_2022.svgbt_instagram_over_2022.svg
  • Login
  • Register
  • Login
  • Register
  • The Korea Times
  • search
  • all menu
  • Login
  • Subscribe
  • Photos
  • Video
  • World
  • Sports
  • Opinion
  • Entertainment & Art
  • Lifestyle
  • Finance
  • Business
  • National
  • North Korea
  • 1

    Family of 5 found dead in 3 separate locations

  • 3

    All-Korean showdowns set up on 1st day of medal race

  • 5

    Opposition party leader ends 24-day hunger strike for treatment

  • 7

    Exhibition for soldiers highlights North Korea's human rights abuses

  • 9

    Sil-A overcomes stage fright, and them some

  • 11

    Historic NASA asteroid mission set for perilous return

  • 13

    Hangzhou Asian Games open after COVID-enforced delay

  • 15

    Korea looking to hit ground running on 1st day of medal events

  • 17

    Korea's top-ranked Go player wants to capitalize on rare chance

  • 19

    EU does not want to decouple from China but must protect itself: EU trade chief

  • 2

    Xi says he will seriously consider visit to South Korea: official

  • 4

    Understanding Korean Modernization

  • 6

    Bears of Joseon part 1: Fanciful tales and deadly claws

  • 8

    US finalizes national security 'guardrails' for CHIPS funding

  • 10

    PM departs for China for Asian Games, meeting with Xi

  • 12

    Allies vow stern measures against Russia-NK arms deal

  • 14

    Top diplomats of Korea, Iran discuss bilateral ties following frozen funds transfer

  • 16

    League of Legends, other esports join Asian Games in competition for first time

  • 18

    Yoon returns home from New York trip

  • 20

    The ethical issues of AI: fighting the right battles

Close scrollclosebutton

Close for 24 hours

Open
  • The Korea Times
  • search
  • all menu
  • Login
  • Subscribe
  • Photos
  • Video
  • World
  • Sports
  • Opinion
  • Entertainment & Art
  • Lifestyle
  • Finance
  • Business
  • National
  • North Korea
Opinion
  • Yun Byung-se
  • Kim Won-soo
  • Ahn Ho-young
  • Kim Sang-woo
  • Lee Kyung-hwa
  • Mitch Shin
  • Peter S. Kim
  • Daniel Shin
  • Jeon Su-mi
  • Jang Daul
  • Song Kyung-jin
  • Park Jung-won
  • Cho Hee-kyoung
  • Park Chong-hoon
  • Kim Sung-woo
  • Donald Kirk
  • John Burton
  • Robert D. Atkinson
  • Mark Peterson
  • Eugene Lee
  • Rushan Ziatdinov
  • Lee Jong-eun
  • Chyung Eun-ju and Joel Cho
  • Bernhard J. Seliger
  • Imran Khalid
  • Troy Stangarone
  • Jason Lim
  • Casey Lartigue, Jr.
  • Bernard Rowan
  • Steven L. Shields
  • Deauwand Myers
  • John J. Metzler
  • Andrew Hammond
  • Sandip Kumar Mishra
Mon, September 25, 2023 | 06:32
Sandip Kumar Mishra
Justice and wartime forced labor
Posted : 2021-09-15 16:55
Updated : 2021-09-15 16:55
Print PreviewPrint Preview
Font Size UpFont Size Up
Font Size DownFont Size Down
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • kakaolink
  • whatsapp
  • reddit
  • mailto
  • link
By Sandip Kumar Mishra

In 1924, a British court gave a very famous axiom of jurisprudence. It said, "Not only must justice be done, but it also must be seen to be done." While keeping the essence of the axiom intact, let's paraphrase it: "Justice must not only be seen to be done, but it must be done."

However, if one narrowly focuses on "justice must be seen to be done" and does not give much consideration for the actual realization of justice, the approach does not serve its purpose.

South Korean courts, both local as well as the Supreme Court, must introspect on whether their judgments on the issue of wartime forced labor by Japanese companies do not fall into the last category. From 2018, there have been several cases and several verdicts in South Korean courts on the issue. In October 2018, the Supreme Court of Korea upheld lower courts' orders in which Japanese companies were asked to pay 100 million won ($85,000) to each of the plaintiffs as reparation.

However, in June, August and September 2021, the Seoul District Court dismissed compensation appeals of the descendants of the wartime forced labor victims. In the most recent verdict on Sept. 8, the court rejected a lawsuit filed by four children of the late victim, surnamed Jeong, against Nippon Steel Corp.

Without being overly emotional about the issue, it must be evaluated whether these judgments have contributed to serving justice to the victims. There is no denial of the fact that the several Koreans suffered immensely because of the wartime forced labor. However, there are many vexing questions which should be considered before taking up and adjudicating this issue.

First and foremost, it must be ascertained whether these Japanese companies acted as per their own free will, or did the Japanese state direct them to do so? If the Japanese state dictated or influenced the decisions of these companies, the state must be made liable for it.

Second, is it not reasonable that the economic reparation provided by Japan to Korea through the Normalization Treaty of 1965 was basically indirect compensation by Japan to these Korean victims and many more? Someone may ask that if individual Korean victims are entitled to sue Japanese companies separately, then what were the specific reasons for the Japanese compensation to Korea?

Third, most of the Korean litigants are second or third generation descendants of the Korean victims who suffered because of the forced-labor. Is it possible to redeem those atrocities by paying compensation to these descendants? Would there not be a time limitation of demanding compensation for the wrong doings of the past? This is important, because history is full of many such atrocities and trying to seek compensation for all of them may, rather than provide justice, bring more animosity.

Fourth, is it easy to get compensation from the Japanese companies given that they are foreign companies in Korea? Also it must be realized that there are various international bodies related to global trade who would definitely come into the picture and make the actualization of the compensation at least complex, if not impossible.

Fifth, if Japanese companies are forced to pay compensation, how is it going to be read by other Japanese companies in Korea? If other Japanese companies decide to curtail their business in Korea because of the lessons they learned from the compensation issue, it would have a negative impact on the Korean economy. It would also mean that many more Korean people are going to suffer in the process.

Sixth, can we be sure that these court verdicts are not going to have impacts on t bilateral relations between Korea and Japan? When China's assertions in the region have grown, North Korean nuclear and missile programs pose existential threats to both Korea and Japan, the US commitment to Korea and Japan is doubtful and several historical and territorial issues between Korea and Japan are already posing serious questions to both Korea and Japan, is it appropriate to raise such a vexatious issue which may further strain bilateral relations?

Actually, without comprehending and answering these questions, it would not be constructive for the courts in Korea to give their verdicts on the forced-labor issue. The point is not that the atrocities were not committed. But it only means that in the process of the delivery of justice, these points must be taken into account.

If it does not happen, justice may appear to be done, but the realization of justice may remain elusive. Apparently, the South Korean state is aware of these complexities and has been trying to tread constructively without hurting Korean popular sentiment or the judiciary. It is high time for Korean courts to also keep in mind the bigger picture.


The author (sandipmishra10@gmail.com
) is associate professor at Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi, India.


 
miguel
Top 10 Stories
1Korea, Saudi Arabia celebrate 93rd Saudi National Day, vow stronger cooperation Korea, Saudi Arabia celebrate 93rd Saudi National Day, vow stronger cooperation
2Seoul, Beijing try to mend fences as Russia and N. Korea grow closerSeoul, Beijing try to mend fences as Russia and N. Korea grow closer
3Samsung, SK relieved by revised chip restrictions on China Samsung, SK relieved by revised chip restrictions on China
4Mirae Asset Global Investments' AUM reaches $219 bil. Mirae Asset Global Investments' AUM reaches $219 bil.
5Bears of Joseon part 2: Behind bars Bears of Joseon part 2: Behind bars
6S. Korea to stage massive military parade as tensions with North remain highS. Korea to stage massive military parade as tensions with North remain high
7JTI Korea joins Jongno clean-up JTI Korea joins Jongno clean-up
8Patients, doctors at loggerheads as operating room CCTV footage made mandatoryPatients, doctors at loggerheads as operating room CCTV footage made mandatory
9Lee Jae-myung's possible arrest looms over main opposition party Lee Jae-myung's possible arrest looms over main opposition party
10FSS warns fisheries cooperatives over sloppy response to failed overseas investment FSS warns fisheries cooperatives over sloppy response to failed overseas investment
Top 5 Entertainment News
1[INTERVIEW] Yim Si-wan went extra mile to portray legendary athlete in 'Road to Boston' INTERVIEWYim Si-wan went extra mile to portray legendary athlete in 'Road to Boston'
2TEMPEST gears up to showcase fiery passion TEMPEST gears up to showcase fiery passion
3BLACKPINK's contract renewal still in limbo BLACKPINK's contract renewal still in limbo
4[INTERVIEW] Virtual K-pop group MAVE: is more than just pretty pixels INTERVIEWVirtual K-pop group MAVE: is more than just pretty pixels
5Hebrew University students travel to Korea to explore musical landscape Hebrew University students travel to Korea to explore musical landscape
DARKROOM
  • Turkey-Syria earthquake

    Turkey-Syria earthquake

  • Nepal plane crash

    Nepal plane crash

  • Brazil capital uprising

    Brazil capital uprising

  • Happy New Year 2023

    Happy New Year 2023

  • World Cup 2022 Final - Argentina vs France

    World Cup 2022 Final - Argentina vs France

CEO & Publisher : Oh Young-jin
Digital News Email : webmaster@koreatimes.co.kr
Tel : 02-724-2114
Online newspaper registration No : 서울,아52844
Date of registration : 2020.02.05
Masthead : The Korea Times
Copyright © koreatimes.co.kr. All rights reserved.
  • About Us
  • Introduction
  • History
  • Contact Us
  • Products & Services
  • Subscribe
  • E-paper
  • RSS Service
  • Content Sales
  • Site Map
  • Policy
  • Code of Ethics
  • Ombudsman
  • Privacy Statement
  • Terms of Service
  • Copyright Policy
  • Family Site
  • Hankook Ilbo
  • Dongwha Group